Forced blood draw of probationer suspected of DUI does not violate the Fourth Amendment The People, v. Manuel Miramontes Cruz, Jr. F074667, Filed 4/25/2019; 2019 WL 1856600 Probationer with a prior DUI conviction refuses to consent to chemical DUI test Defendant Manuel Miramontes Cruz, Jr., was charged with driving under…
Articles Posted in New Case Law
Habeas Petition Granted to Vacate Special Circumstances In Felony Murder Conviction
Anthony Taylor filed a habeas petition claiming that his special circumstance finding in a felony murder conviction should be vacated due to insufficient evidence based on recent caselaw. His petition, filed 20 years after finality of direct review, was considered timely because it was brought within a year of that…
Using criminal process to collect court fees and assessments from indigents is unconstitutional
Defendants who plead or are found guilty of traffic violations and other misdemeanors are typically assessed court fees and fines under Gov. Code, § 70373, Pen. Code, § 1465.8, and Pen. Code, § 1202.4, Unpaid fines usually go to collections without further order of the court. Courts must determine a…
New Criminal Cases Law
Lawyer cannot override client’s decision to maintain innocence Roberto Ignacio Flores was charged with attempted murder of a police officer and insisted he was not the driver of the car that injured the officer. His lawyer wanted to admit that Flores was driving the car but that he never formed…
California Supreme Court rules that a partial verdict of acquittal on first degree murder prevents retrial on that charge
People v. Aranda; S214116 The California Supreme Court reaffirmed its past holding that a court must accept a partial verdict of acquittal as to a charged greater offense when a jury has expressly indicated it has acquitted on that offense but has deadlocked on uncharged lesser included offenses. [Stone v.…
Recent Criminal Case Law
Lawyer cannot concede client is guilty when client insists on a defense of factual innocence Defendant was found guilty of first degree murder and using a knife in the commission of the crime after his lawyer conceded his guilt of voluntary manslaughter during closing argument. Defendant’s request to replace counsel…
Supreme Court: 8th Amendment bars execution of prisoner with dementia
The State of Alabama set an execution date for prisoner who then asserted an Eight Amendment Claim because his mental condition, relating to a series of strokes, rendered him incapable of recollecting committing the crime for which he had been sentenced to die. The Alabama Circuit Court found that the…
Recent Criminal Case Law
Law enforcement may use social media to gain incriminating information about a suspect. A jury convicted Chaz Nasjhee Pride of robbery and found true allegations he committed the robbery for the benefit of a criminal street gang. Pride argued that his rights under the Fourth Amendment to the United…
U.S. Supreme Court rules that the excessive fines clause applies to the states and civil foreiftures
Police in Indians arrested seized Tyson Timb’s for dealing in a controlled substance and conspiracy to commit theft. They seized his Land Rover that he had purchased for $42,000 with money he received from an insurance policy when his father died.Timbs pleaded guilty and the State sought forfeiture of his…